Winter Tyres vs All-Season Tyres: What’s Best for UK Roads?

As you probably know, the weather in the UK can be unpredictable, with wet roads, frost and occasional snowfall all playing a part. This often leaves drivers unsure whether winter tyres or all-season tyres are the better choice. Understanding how each tyre type performs in harsh weather conditions can help you make a confident and informed decision. 

What are winter tyres? 

Winter tyres are specifically designed to perform in cold weather, particularly when temperatures fall below 7°C. They are made from a softer rubber compound that stays flexible in low temperatures, allowing the tyre to maintain grip when summer tyres start to harden and lose effectiveness. 

The tread pattern on winter tyres is deeper and features more grooves and sipes. These help channel water and slush away from the tyre while improving traction on snow and icy surfaces. This design allows winter tyres to offer better braking, steering control and stability during harsh winter conditions. 

What are all-season tyres? 

All-season tyres are designed to deliver balanced performance throughout the year. They sit between summer and winter tyres, combining elements of both to handle a wide range of temperatures and road conditions. Their rubber compound remains usable in both warm and cool weather, while the tread pattern is designed to cope with wet roads and light snow. 

Most modern all-season tyres are marked with the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake symbol, meaning they meet recognised winter performance standards. However, they are not as specialised as winter tyres and are best suited to milder winter conditions. 

How the UK weather affects tyre performance 

The UK rarely experiences heavy snowfall, and when this does happen, it doesn’t last long before thawing again. Usually, cold temperatures, rain and frost are most common between late autumn and early spring. Roads can be damp, icy or greasy, especially during early mornings and in the evenings. These are the conditions where tyre choice makes a noticeable difference. 

Summer tyres begin to lose grip once temperatures drop below 7°C, even if the roads are dry. Both winter tyres and all-season tyres perform better in cold weather, but the level of performance is dependent on the severity of the weather conditions. 

Winter tyres on UK roads 

Winter tyres provide the highest level of safety when temperatures are consistently low or when snow and ice are present. They significantly reduce braking distances and improve traction compared to both summer and all-season tyres in cold conditions. 

For drivers who regularly travel on rural roads, higher ground, or areas that are slower to be gritted, winter tyres can provide valuable peace of mind. They are also a strong option for drivers who commute early in the morning or late at night when frost is more likely. 

However, winter tyres are not designed for year-round use. In warmer temperatures, they can wear more quickly and feel less precise on dry roads, which is why they are typically swapped out once temperatures rise. 

All-season tyres on UK roads 

All-season tyres are a popular choice for UK drivers who want a single tyre solution throughout the year. They perform well in wet and cool conditions and offer improved grip compared to summer tyres during colder months. 

In light snow or frosty conditions, all-season tyres provide reliable performance for most everyday driving situations. They are particularly suited to urban driving and areas where severe winter weather is rare or short-lived. 

While all-season tyres cannot match the cold-weather performance of dedicated winter tyres, they offer a practical balance of safety, convenience and cost for many UK motorists. 

Cost and convenience considerations 

Running two sets of tyres, summer and winter, involves higher upfront costs and seasonal fitting. Storage can also be a consideration if you do not have space at home. For some drivers, this makes winter tyres less practical despite their performance benefits. 

All-season tyres remove the need for seasonal tyre changes, making them more convenient and often more cost-effective in the long term. For drivers covering average annual mileage and frequently experiencing mild winters, this convenience can outweigh the performance gap. 

Winter tyres vs all-season tyres: side-by-side comparison 

Feature	Winter Tyres	All Season Tyres
Best operating temperature	Below 7°C	Wide range, cold to warm conditions
Rubber compound	Softer compound that stays flexible in cold weather	Balanced compound designed for year-round use
Grip in cold weather	Excellent	Good
Performance in snow and ice	Very strong traction and braking	Suitable for light snow and slush
Wet road performance	Very good in cold, wet conditions	Very good year-round
Dry road performance	Less responsive in warmer temperatures	Stable and predictable
Tread design	Deep tread with heavy siping for snow and ice	Moderate tread designed for mixed conditions
Braking distance in winter	Shortest braking distances	Longer than winter tyres but shorter than summer tyres
Year-round suitability	No, seasonal use only	Yes
Convenience	Requires seasonal changeover	No tyre change needed
Typical UK use case	Rural driving, cold regions, frequent frost or snow	Urban driving, mild winters, mixed conditions

 

Which option is right for you? 

If you regularly drive in colder regions, rural areas or places where snow and ice are more common, winter tyres provide the best option for safety and handling during winter. They are particularly beneficial if your driving schedule exposes you to untreated roads or frequent frosty conditions. 

If your driving is mainly urban, your area experiences mild winters, and you want a single tyre solution that performs well all year, all-season tyres are likely to be the better choice. They offer dependable performance without the hassle of changing tyres twice a year. 

 

Choosing tyres with Merityre 

At Merityre, we offer a wide range of winter tyres and all-season tyres to suit different vehicles, driving habits and budgets. Our experienced team can help you choose the right tyres based on your location, mileage and typical driving conditions, ensuring you stay safe and confident on UK roads throughout the year. 

If you’re unsure which option is best for your car, visiting your local Merityre centre for expert advice and fitting can make all the difference. 

Find your local branch